Browse All Midnight Harbor Sub Properties for Sale

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Midnight Harbor Sub SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code

Under contract-accepting backup offers. Prime waterfront rebuild opportunity on Siesta Key. Tear-down structure on property. Selling for land value only. AS IS situation. Investor or builder's dream! High-equity potential in a neighborhood of multi-million dollar luxury estates. The existing home is heavily storm-damaged and is being sold strictly for lot value. While the existing structure has sustained significant damage from two recent hurricanes, the true value lies in the land, the location, and the limitless potential for a custom waterfront estate. AS IS seawall. Bring your architect, your builder, and your vision. Embrace the ultimate coastal lifestyle with this rare blank canvas on world-renowned Siesta Key. Nestled on a highly coveted bayside lot, this property offers breathtaking water views and access. All this just minutes from one of the best beaches in the world. Walk or drive to dinner and shopping. Half a mile south to the Stickney Point Bridge. Twenty minutes from beautiful downtown Sarasota.

7425 Midnight Pass Road, Sarasota

$2,750,000

Midnight Harbor Sub SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code

A rare opportunity on Siesta Key’s Little Sarasota Bay. Positioned at the end of a quiet street in the established Midnight Harbor neighborhood, this 0.45-acre bayfront lot offers 287 feet of water frontage, approximately 92 feet along the bay and 195 feet along a protected saltwater canal, creating water on two sides and expansive open water views. The property is being offered for land value and presents an exceptional canvas for a new custom bayfront estate. The existing structure is not being marketed for renovation, allowing a buyer or builder to focus fully on designing a residence that maximizes the site’s orientation, water views and waterfront lifestyle potential. The bayside seawall was replaced in 2014, along with 20 feet of canal seawall. The protected canal frontage provides practical boating access with sailboat water and no fixed bridges, allowing direct navigation to the Intracoastal Waterway and Gulf beyond. The depth of the lot and the dual water exposure create compelling opportunities for architectural design, outdoor living spaces and waterfront amenities. The site is enhanced by mature coastal trees that contribute character and scale, elements often absent in newly created waterfront parcels. With nearly half an acre and substantial waterfront exposure, the property offers the scale required for a significant new coastal residence designed to modern building standards and elevated construction. Just minutes from Siesta Beach and offering convenient access to the mainland via the Stickney Point Bridge, the setting combines island privacy with proximity to Sarasota’s dining, cultural and entertainment districts. Waterfront redevelopment opportunities with this amount of bay and canal frontage on Siesta Key are increasingly limited, making this property a compelling investment for a builder, developer or buyer seeking to create a legacy waterfront home.

1267 Starboard Lane, Sarasota

$2,750,000

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Midnight Harbor Sub SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code

A compelling canvas for architectural vision on the shores of Little Sarasota Bay. At the end of a quiet street in the established Siesta Key Midnight Harbor neighborhood, 1267 Starboard Lane offers a rare opportunity to design and construct a modern bayfront residence on one of the island’s distinctive waterfront sites. This .45-acre property features 287 feet of water frontage, with approximately 92 feet along the open bay and 195 feet along a protected canal, creating water exposure on two sides and expansive views across Little Sarasota Bay. The orientation allows a future residence to capture sweeping water vistas, coastal breezes, and memorable sunsets while also benefiting from the calm, protected canal frontage for boating access. The existing structure is being offered for land value, presenting an ideal opportunity to design a new residence that reflects today’s elevated coastal architecture and modern building standards. With generous frontage and lot depth, the site offers excellent flexibility for thoughtful design, allowing a future home to integrate elevated living levels, expansive terraces, resort-style outdoor spaces, and seamless indoor-outdoor connections that embrace the surrounding waterfront environment. The bayside frontage is enhanced by a seawall (2014), while the canal side provides sailboat water with no fixed bridges, offering direct access to the Intracoastal Waterway and Gulf beyond. Mature coastal trees add scale and natural beauty to the property, creating an established setting rarely found on newly developed waterfront parcels. Just moments from the white quartz sands of Siesta Beach and with convenient access to mainland Sarasota via the Stickney Point Bridge, the location offers a balance of island privacy and proximity to Sarasota’s vibrant arts, dining and cultural amenities. For architects, builders, or buyers seeking to create a distinctive new waterfront residence, this property presents an exceptional opportunity to shape the next chapter of Siesta Key living.

1267 Starboard Lane, Sarasota

$1,850,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Midnight Harbor Sub SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code

Siesta Key Waterfront Canal Home - Experience the best of waterfront living on Siesta Key with this charming canal-front home, just one house from the open bay and offering quick, easy access to the Intracoastal Waterway. Nestled in a tranquil and highly desirable location, the property enjoys a private setting on an expansive lot with a wide canal and stunning views of Sarasota Bay. This well-designed 3-bedroom, 2-bath residence sits high and dry, featuring an open floor plan perfect for entertaining. The spacious living and dining rooms flow seamlessly into the kitchen and family room, all enhanced by high ceilings and natural light. The master suite includes a cozy sitting area—ideal for a home office, den, or hobby room. On cooler evenings, relax by the wood-burning fireplace in the family room while watching boats drift by the bay. Outdoor living is equally inviting, with a sparkling pool and spa that provide the perfect retreat on warm Florida days. For boating enthusiasts, the property includes a dock equipped with a boat lift, water, electricity, swim ladder, and sundeck. Enjoy fishing, swimming, kayaking, or paddle-boarding right from your backyard. Upgrades include Roof (5 years old), A/C (3 years old). All hurricane impact windows & sliders and a 2 Car Garage. This home offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of Siesta Key waterfront—where every day feels like a vacation.

1236 Port Lane, Sarasota

$1,475,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Midnight Harbor Sub SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code

This is a stunning waterfront retreat with endless potential. Nestled in a tranquil and highly desirable location, this charming waterfront residence offers an unlimited opportunity to be part of the Florida lifestyle. Situated on an expansive lot along a scenic wide canal, this home is just three properties away from the open Bay, to ensure breathtaking views and immediately access to boating, sailing, fishing, and all your favorite water activities. This home features 3 bedrooms and 2 baths with functional layout that invites personalization. Whether you choose to make enhancements to the existing structure or undertake a complete rebuild to suit your unique tastes, the possibilities are endless. The outdoor space is equally impressive, with a private courtyard that boasts a sparkling pool and a soothing jacuzzi—perfect for relaxing in the sun or cooling off on warm days. For boating enthusiasts, the property is equipped with a boat lift, while the spacious Tiki hut offers a wonderful space for entertaining or simply unwinding in the shade. Enjoy the cool breeze and watch stunning sunsets over the canal, all from your own backyard. This oversized lot offers an extraordinary opportunity to create your dream home or preserve the current residence as your ultimate waterfront getaway. With a prime location just minutes from the open Bay, this is a rare chance to own your own slice of paradise. Don’t miss out.

1231 Starboard Lane, Sarasota

$2,150,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Midnight Harbor Sub SubDv. ⋅ 34242 Zip Code

Located on a quiet lane on Siesta Key, this beautiful waterfront home is a RARE OPPORTUNITY TO OWN A SARASOTA SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE LEGACY! Designed by the Father of Sarasota School of Architecture, Ralph Twitchell, in 1960 when he had perfected his homes for Florida living. Like many homes of the era, this residence lives much larger than its square footage would imply, as there are many screened areas, breezeways, and covered spaces. Entering the home through ornamental red gates, you are in a covered foyer breezeway with a flowing koi pond beside your feet. Instantly your senses become calm as your view moves through to palm trees and sailboat water. With two distinctly different home structures (the guest area and main living area), the guest structure has 2 bedrooms and a bathroom that open to the back lanai, hot tub, second koi pond and to water views beyond. The main living area has expansive sliding glass doors and clerestory windows, exposed beams and continuous pecky cypress wood ceilings that extend outside to the beautiful pool oasis and sailboat water with views leading out to Sarasota bay. The integrity of the MID-CENTURY-MODERN aesthetics immerse you in the space with its Ocala block walls, terrazzo floors, cypress walls and inviting wood burning fireplace. The kitchen has been tastefully updated with birch cabinetry & granite counters that open to the living space with a large open bar top. There is a quaint outside screened dining patio between the kitchen and garage that opens up to views of the sky. The primary suite has maintained the mid-century modern look with many built-in closets and dressers, as well as a floating birch counter in the bathroom. There is an accessory building on the property that features a spa-like atmosphere with cork flooring and a full size cedar sauna enclosed within the space. The southern facing pool area has an extended roof line providing sunshade, and a constant light show where sunlight reflects and dances tranquilly from the canal and pool. The shelled yard leads you to many outdoor spaces under shaded palm trees, 131’ of new seawall, a dock and boat lift. Close to Siesta Key beach accesses, and many restaurant choices just down the road, this home is a one-of-a-kind opportunity. Perfect for those who love nature, love Siesta Key, love architecture, and want to buy a piece of history!

1224 Port Lane, Sarasota

Start Your Search

Midnight Harbor Sub Real Estate & Homes

Our website features the best real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available in Midnight Harbor Sub, Siesta Key FL. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!