Quick Siesta Key FL MLS Search

Browse All Turtle Bay Properties for Sale

$810,000
3 Beds 3 Baths Turtle Bay SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
LARGE 3 BED / 3 BATH SIESTA KEY WATERVIEW CONDO WITH A LARGE GARAGE AT A GREAT PRICE! Natural light and panoramic water views fill this spacious three-bedroom, three-bath end-unit residence in the sought-after Bayside community of Turtle Bay on Siesta Key. From the glass-enclosed lanai, enjoy breathtaking sunrises as boats glide along the Intracoastal Waterway, and in the evening, take in the sunset from the west-facing front lanai. The home’s kitchen and all three baths have been tastefully remodeled. The kitchen features a raised ceiling with recessed lighting, updated cabinetry, granite countertops, and premium Samsung appliances. Each bath offers elegant finishes, including glass-enclosed showers or tubs, wood cabinetry, and attractive flooring. The generously sized primary suite offers a beautifully updated en-suite bath. A second oversized guest bedroom is also en-suite with tranquil western views of the manicured grounds. Additional features include a new AC (2023), 40-gallon Rheem water heater (2020), indoor laundry room, and your own under-building private parking garage for storage, convenience, and security. No need to carry your beach chairs and accessories up to your condo, just put them in your private 12 X 28 garage with a 7x7 storage area on the ground level. Turtle Bay is a premier south Siesta Key community known for its lush tropical landscaping and exceptional amenities—updated fishing pier, boat dock with available slips (first-come, first-served), kayak launch, clubhouse, heated pool and spa, grilling area, and lighted tennis courts. Best of all, residents enjoy deeded Beach access just across the street to the Gulf of Mexico, where dazzling sunsets await. Experience the perfect blend of waterfront tranquility, resort-style living, and Siesta Key’s signature coastal charm at Turtle Bay. This condo is being sold TURNKEY - everything stays - just back your bags because everything else is already here! Milestone inspection and report has been completed and is available for potential buyers to review.

8735 Midnight Pass Road Unit 301B, Sarasota

$630,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Turtle Bay SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
New Price! The best of bayfront living on Siesta Key with deeded beach access and boat slips. Experience the best of island living in this impeccably renovated bayfront residence at Turtle Bay, ideally on the serene southern end of world-renowned Siesta Key. Wake each morning to spectacular sunrises over the Intracoastal Waterway and wind down with vibrant sunsets near the beach—this is the quintessential Florida lifestyle. This spacious and stylish two-bedroom, two-bath condominium has been thoughtfully redesigned, including raised ceilings that enhance the open, airy feel. Throughout the home, you'll find designer tile flooring and elegant plantation shutters. The gourmet kitchen and both baths have been beautifully updated with crisp white wood cabinetry, stone countertops and sleek stainless steel appliances, creating a bright, modern coastal aesthetic. Enjoy gentle bay breezes from the screened terrace or relax in comfort indoors. A convenient full laundry room offers additional storage, and an oversized private one-car garage adds extra value and ease. Pet friendly, Turtle Bay offers an exceptional array of amenities, including beautifully landscaped bayfront grounds, deeded beach access directly across Midnight Pass Road, a heated pool and spa, tennis courts, boat slips (available on a first-come, first-served basis), and a charming picnic and grilling area. Minutes to the South Village, you'll enjoy effortless access via the free trolley to shopping, dining and entertainment, and a short ride to Siesta Village's unique shops and eateries. Nearby Point of Rocks is a favorite destination for snorkeling and fishing. Just minutes from Stickney Point Bridge and only 20 minutes to downtown Sarasota’s vibrant arts, culture and culinary scene, this condominium offers the best of Siesta Key living. Whether you're seeking a tranquil retreat or an active coastal lifestyle, this residence delivers it all.

8701 Midnight Pass Road Unit 104, Sarasota

$618,500
2 Beds 2 Baths Turtle Bay SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Penthouse Opportunity in Turtle Bay - Siesta Key. Building B has a new roof and has passed both its Milestone & SIRS Inspections, and all special assessments have been paid by Seller. Welcome to Turtle Bay, one of Siesta Key’s most beloved bayside communities where sugar-soft Gulf beaches meet the serene beauty of Little Sarasota Bay. Perched on the top floor, this rarely available penthouse residence offers a unique opportunity to add value and design your dream coastal escape. Unit 602B features a 2bed 2 bath split layout floorplan and an in-unit stackable washer and dryer; a rare convenience on the Key. These penthouse bones are strong, pride of ownership is abundant, and you can feel the energy of love inside, making this opportunity ideal for those seeking a personalized second home or hybrid investment. Step outside and enjoy an array of premium amenities: a heated bayfront pool & spa, updated fishing pier, kayak launch and storage, tennis and pickleball courts, a community grilling area, and a social clubhouse. Boaters will love the available dock slips for just $300/year, while beach lovers can stroll across the street to access the deeded Gulf-front beach access. Turtle Bay is beautifully maintained and ideally located on the tranquil southern end of the island, and just minutes to the restaurants, shops, and free trolley stops that make Siesta living so effortless. Whether you're envisioning winters away from the Midwest chill, or a lock-and-leave getaway with flexible 3-month minimum rental options (up to 4x per year), this penthouse is your canvas.

8735 Midnight Pass Road Unit 602B, Sarasota

$455,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Turtle Bay SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Endless Potential in a Prime Location! Located in the highly desirable Turtle Bay on South Siesta Key, this two-bedroom, two-bath condo is a blank canvas- original and ready for its new owner to bring their vision to life. With stunning views of Little Sarasota Bay from the living room and private balcony, this unit offers the perfect foundation to create your dream coastal retreat. Enjoy access to an updated fishing pier-ideal for casting a line or simply soaking in the stunning water views. Boaters will love the private boat dock with boat slips available for just $300 a year, making it easy and affordable to explore the waterways. Additional community amenities ensure every day feels like a vacation along with a deeded beach access just across the street at Tortuga Community for direct access to the sparkling Gulf of Mexico waters world-famous sunsets. Inside, you'll find an open-concept layout, generous natural light, spacious bedrooms, and private balcony where you can take in the tranquil waterfront scenery overlooking the pool. The spacious layout provides an ideal backdrop for your renovation and personalization. Whether you're dreaming of a modern beach-chic aesthetic or a cozy Florida getaway, the possibilities are endless. Residents enjoy deeded beach access across the street, providing easy entry to the gulf and gorgeous sunsets! Additional highlights include a private detached garage, plenty of guest parking, and located minutes away from Siesta Key Village, shopping, dining and entertainment. Enjoy all the amenities at Turtle Bay which include a heated pool, tennis and pickleball courts, clubhouse, and fishing pier with day dockage. With the beach just a short walk away, this is your chance to own and transform a piece of paradise on Siesta Key.

8701 Midnight Pass Road Unit 206A, Sarasota

$650,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Turtle Bay SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Welcome to this beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom condo located in the highly sought-after bayside community of Turtle Bay on Siesta Key. Tucked away on the serene south end of the island, this spacious unit offers views of Little Sarasota Bay and a truly effortless coastal lifestyle. The interior features thoughtful upgrades including travertine flooring, solid-surface countertops, GE appliances, new cabinetry, a reverse osmosis system, and plantation shutters that fill the home with natural light. You’ll love the oversized hurricane-impact sliding windows in the living area and lanai, designed to frame water views and invite in those island breezes. A full-size stackable washer and dryer is conveniently located in a separate in-unit laundry/storage room—something rarely found in Siesta condos! Turtle Bay offers a host of top-tier amenities, including a heated pool, hot tub, clubhouse, grill and picnic area, lighted tennis and pickleball courts, a newly updated fishing pier, and a boat dock with slips available for just $300/year. Deeded beach access is located just across the street via the neighboring Tortuga community, allowing you to dip your toes in Siesta’s world-famous powdery white sand and take in nightly sunsets on the Gulf. Additional highlights include a private detached garage and plenty of guest parking. The community recently passed its Milestone Inspection, and the grounds are impeccably maintained. Located just minutes from Siesta Key Village, shopping, dining, and entertainment, with convenient access to the free Siesta Key trolley. Whether you’re searching for a full-time island residence, seasonal escape, or an investment opportunity, this condo is ready for its next chapter. The only reason it’s available is because the seller’s mother, who recently purchased the unit, now needs to transition into assisted living offering you a rare opportunity to enjoy all the benefits of an updated, move-in ready home in one of Siesta Key’s most cherished communities.

8735 Midnight Pass Road Unit 306B, Sarasota

$750,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Turtle Bay SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Would you like to live in a beautiful resort area but could do without the traffic and the tourists? Then welcome to Turtle Bay at the quiet end of Siesta Key. This community is close enough to the excitement of the bars, restaurants and shopping of Siesta Key, yet has a discreet elegance that allows you to relax and enjoy your own portion of paradise. This well-maintained fourth floor condominium is turn-key furnished and boasts a full panoramic view looking east to the Intracoastal Waterway on Little Sarasota Bay. This is handy because you will be able to see your own boat in the community marina. The updated kitchen features beige cabinets, new LG stainless steel appliances, granite countertops with an open pass-through to the dining area, and room for a workspace or breakfast nook. The open living and dining room leads to the spacious screened-in lanai creating one large entertaining space. The Master Bedroom also features new furniture, a private entrance to the lanai as well as spacious closets and en-suite bath. A guest bedroom, bath and in-unit laundry complete the interior spaces. The garage has sufficient space for your car, all of your beach toys, golf clubs, and snow blower. Turtle Bay amenities include deeded beach access, a heated pool and spa, tennis courts, pickle ball, a picnic area with natural gas grills in a manicured setting overlooking the bay, and boat slips available to all owners to lease annually. 2023 upgrades include new HVAC equipment with a Wi-Fi thermostat that allows you to maintain the temperature inside the unit remotely, new kitchen appliances, new master bedroom furniture and a 65” Samsung Television. The current owners have a signed contract with Sarasota Glass and have already paid for the full replacement of the windows and outer sliders with top of the line PGT Winguard Bronze Aluminum Insulated Impact Mak Low E glass with the Miami Dade Ct5 designation. The contract fully conveys with the property to the new owners and the windows can be installed after closing.

8735 Midnight Pass Road Unit 406B, Sarasota

$1,240,000
3 Beds 3 Baths Turtle Bay SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
With an incredible view of the Intracoastal Waterway, two large lanais, and 1,922 interior square footage, this impeccably remodeled three-bedroom end-unit on the fourth floor features high end finishes, all new windows, hardwood floors, and plantation shutters in the living areas and two bedrooms, crown molding, three custom baths, and multiple closets with organizers. The sellers installed all new impact-resistant windows throughout the condominium as well as in the large enclosed lanai off the living room where they have year-round use and enjoyment of spectacular sunrises over the water. In 2019, the kitchen was upgraded with GE appliances and a water filter system. Additionally, the residence was repainted and new light fixtures put in, bedroom blinds added (2023), and the HVAC replaced (2020). The private enclosed under-building garage has been updated with Amish word-work throughout, including storage cabinets and work bench. This Bayside community of Turtle Bay on the south end of world-famous Siesta Key has lush landscaping, a newly updated fishing pier, and a boat dock with slips available on a first-come, first-serve basis, kayak launch, heated pool, clubhouse, grill and picnic area, lighted tennis courts, and pickleball courts. And just across the street, one can enjoy the deeded beach access to the sparkling Gulf waters and the most gorgeous sunsets.

8701 Midnight Pass Road Unit 407A, Sarasota

$650,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Turtle Bay SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Motivated Sellers. Experience coastal luxury at its finest with this turn-key furnished, well maintained 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom condo in the coveted Turtle Bay community on Siesta Key. Offering coveted beach access, a community pool with serene water views, convenient boat slips alongside a charming fishing dock and private garages with storage, this residence epitomizes waterfront living at its best. Step inside to discover a spacious and luminous interior, accentuated by tasteful finishes and breathtaking views of the Intercoastal Waterway. The open layout seamlessly integrates the living, dining, and kitchen areas, fostering an inviting ambiance ideal for relaxation and entertaining alike. Retreat to the master suite, boasting a walk-in closet, dual sinks, a vanity, and a generously-sized walk-in shower. The second bedroom provides ample space for guests or family members, ensuring everyone's comfort and privacy. Outside, indulge in resort-style amenities including the waterfront pool, private beach access, and available boat slips perfect for boating enthusiasts. With Siesta Key Beach just a short stroll away, enjoy endless opportunities for swimming, sunbathing, and water sports right at your doorstep. Conveniently located near the trolley stop, exploring Siesta Key's vibrant villages and their plethora of restaurants and shops is a breeze. Whether you seek a permanent residence, a vacation getaway, or an investment opportunity, this condo in Turtle Bay promises to exceed your expectations. Don't miss out on the ultimate coastal living experience – schedule your private showing today!

8735 Midnight Pass Road Unit 502B, Sarasota

$685,000
2 Beds 2 Baths Turtle Bay SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Absolutely stunning. Turtle Bay condo with 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, bay views, Brand New boat and fishing docks and beach access. Inside this spacious condo you will find a beautiful kitchen with a cozy built-in office space off the front, stainless steel appliances, easy-to-clean tile flooring, tray ceilings and a breakfast bar that overlooks the dining and living areas allowing for picturesque water views! Being SOLD TURNKEY FURNISHED. The primary suite is generously sized and includes an attached en-suite bathroom, walk-in closet, and a private entrance to the enclosed lanai. The second bedroom offers ample storage in the double closets. Convenience is key with an indoor laundry room featuring a full-size washer and dryer. Off the back the enclosed lanai allows you to enjoy the beautiful landscape and surroundings year-round. One unique feature of this property is the private garage and storage space located under the building. The Turtle Bay community provides an array of amenities for its residents to enjoy, including a heated pool and spa, tennis & pickleball courts, a grilling and picnic area, shuffleboard, and various activities. On-site management, secure entry, and two elevators add to the convenience and security of this community! For those who enjoy boating, boat slips are available on a first come, first serve basis. Centrally located, with an abundance of restaurants, shopping, and recreational activities. Nearby Turtle Beach, Siesta Beach and Siesta Village easily accessible by free trolley. This rare opportunity offers a truly remarkable living experience. Create lasting memories in this pet-friendly condo at Turtle Bay, call today to schedule your tour before it’s gone!

8701 Midnight Pass Road Unit 304A, Sarasota

$1,850,000
3 Beds 3 Baths Turtle Bay SubDv. 34242 Zip Code
Step into the realm of unparalleled luxury at this extraordinary builder's PERSONAL CONDO, an immaculately crafted residence that underwent a meticulous redesign, leaving no detail untouched offered fully furnished. Perched on the coveted Top Floor, this 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom end unit reveals sweeping gulf and bay views, offering a rare perspective to relish both sunrise and sunset panoramas. Indulge your culinary senses in the gourmet chef's kitchen, a masterpiece in itself, featuring waterfall quartz countertops and custom flat-paneled cabinetry throughout the home. The kitchen is equipped with a 36” Italian range, exterior venting range hood, designer Grohe faucets, and a comprehensive full home carbon block filtration system. The master suite, adorned with contemporary wood-patterned tile slats, exudes sophistication, with walk-in closet built-ins, ample storage, and a dual vanity connection. The walk-in showers in both ensuite bathrooms are works of art, complete with custom floating benches, high-end finishes, and extensive low-voltage backlighting throughout. Both of these rooms capture breathtaking intercoastal and Gulf water views from adjoining expansive terraces, while the third bedroom, with bay-view windows, offers versatility to welcome guests or serve as an office. Customizations and upgrades during the remodel process have transformed this slice of paradise into a breathtaking haven of functionality and luxury Nestled within Turtle Bay, this residence redefines care-free condo living with amenities such as a heated pool, fishing pier, three lighted tennis courts, two pickleball courts, grill and picnic area, and newly updated fishing pier and boat docks. A large private enclosed garage under the building adds an exclusive touch to your coastal lifestyle. Enjoy easy access to the Gulf of Mexico with deeded private beach access, boat slips available, and a plethora of community amenities, beckoning you to embrace the pinnacle of modern and coastal luxury living on Siesta Key.

8701 Midnight Pass Road Unit 607A, Sarasota

Start Your Search

Turtle Bay Real Estate & Homes

Our website features the best real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available in Turtle Bay, Siesta Key FL. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!